Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm with Andrews & Arnold. I won't need to tell them anything because I know they take my privacy very seriously. They're the best ISP I've ever dealt with.



Another happy A&A customer here. In a world of every ISP being amazing, they'd take the crown as the best one.

I get an amazingly advanced web UI which lets me do things nobody can do on any other ISPs (advanced options on my line etc). I can get a text/email/tweet whenever my line goes down and back up. I can hop on IRC and talk to sales/tech or even the owner (this[1] is his blog, by the way - He writes a lot, I recommend following him). And needless to say, full ipv6 support.

They're expensive, but that's because they don't oversell bandwidth. People constantly complain about ISPs overselling, but when someone comes along and does not do that, people say "Oh but it's too expensive".

[1]: http://revk.www.me.uk/


These guys look brilliant!

"Even in 2013 it is almost unique to find a "home" package that includes IPv6. In IPv6 ::1 is the address for "Home". Calling it Home127.0.0.1 seemed silly."


I did consider switching to them, but the plan I looked at (Fiber to the cabinet and a higher 200GB download cap) comes in at £50 + (as far as I'm aware) BT line rental, so around £66/month... My BT bill for the above is around £40... Do you think it's worth the extra £26 ish for peace and mind? Are they really that much better than other ISPs? Thanks for the info!

EDIT: Ignore my comment, after reading up on them a bit more, they do seem like a pretty amazing ISP. Thanks for reminding me of them :)


Looks like they've cut their prices with that home::1 offering, I would seriously consider moving back there if I wasn't really satisfied with my current ISP. (I'm with goscomb.net at the moment due to my higher bandwidth requirements - comes in around £20/month cheaper than the equivalent AASIP setup with 450GB/transfer, 80:20 FTTC profile, IPv6 and a /29 IPv4).

Used these guys years ago for bonded ADSL and they were awesome, can't rate them high enough.

To any reasonably well-paid tech professional saving £30/month by going with one of the 'Big Four' ISPs: Buy cheap beef, get horse-meat.


That's pretty much the A&A plan that I have, and I think it's worth it for me. This is a case where you get what you pay for, and I both need an excellent level of service (because I depend on my ISP for work) and can afford to pay for it. The equation would be different for other, say, casual users or people on tight budgets.

Also ... IPv6 just works, and I have a /48 assignment.


A&A doesn't supply enough bandwidth for our home (including work from home) use, at least on their pricing page.

On a 5Mbps line, our average monthly usage was about 300G/month, according to router statistics.

Now that we're on BT FTTC at 76Mbps (rate to nearest speedtest.net when there's no contention), I wouldn't like to guess the usage, but I'd estimate over 1TB a month at least. The BT provided router resets its count every 30 minutes or so, and I've not yet put my own routing box in the middle, so I don't know exactly.

Both my GF and I stream a lot of HD video, and I mirror a number of repositories every week. That video is a lot more HD now, and there's far less need to ever turn it off, since it doesn't significantly affect other users.

A more feasible approach would be to combine A&A with BT, and switch depending on reliability vs bulk requirements, but that would require a level of systems administration I'd want to be compensated for.


I have the 100GB cap and just top up automatically if I go over.


Agreed. It's pretty awesome to be able to hop on to IRC and talk to their engineers and other experts.


Also great to be able to trigger BT's line tests directly from Andrews and Arnold's web interface, see the history of usage, line sync rates, etc. That, and their ability to configure low-delay shaping upstream of BT's backhaul so you don't build big download queues in the DSLAM. Greatly improves my VoIP quality. Another happy customer.


It's surprising that anyone can say that about any ISP. Would you mind elaborating?


It's all explained at http://aaisp.net.uk/kb-broadband-realinternet.html.

This is my favourite part: "Sorry, for a censored internet you will have to pick a different ISP or move to North Korea. Our services are all unfiltered."


When you are trying to sign up you can select a censored option:

>>Censored Internet access - restricted access to unpublished government mandated filter list - but still cannot guarantee kids don't access porn


As explained here: http://aaisp.net.uk/kb-broadband-realinternet.html

The option are:

- Unfiltered Internet access - no filtering of any content within the A&A network - you are responsible for any filtering in your own network, or

- Censored Internet access - restricted access to unpublished government mandated filter list (plus Daily Mail web site) - but still cannot guarantee kids don't access porn.



Deaf customers: We can be contacted using irc, via our web site, text and email.

Just awesome.


It's the first time in my life I see someone praising their ISP, I'm still astonished...


Happened all the time before broadband consolidated the market. I loved most of my dialup ISPs.


I've used them for years. Compared with all the other ISPs they are awesome


Tell them to come to the US please. :)

We need an ISP we'd actually like around here!


Do they provide you with a static IP?


Ah, just found it: Block of IPv6 addresses statically assigned (/48 per customer), and single static IPv4 address.

From http://aaisp.net.uk/broadband-home1-info.html#more


For anyone else wondering how many IP addresses /48 gives you in IPv6 land, it's 65,536!

This page helps with the CIDR notation for IPv6: http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:Range_blocks/IPv6


No it gives you 65536 /64 blocks. Far more IPs than that! You can give every machine a /64, but I only do if they are running containers or VMs.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: