Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Awesome little machine but this brings up questions for me:

1. Do consumers want what is essentially a modern netbook? Didn't this market die once the iPad and tablets took hold?

It would seem from recent consumer buying trends that most prefer a touch screen/tablet form factor at this price point/screen size.

2. How does this compare to an Android tablet (Nexus 10) with a high quality keyboard? Or even some of the "transformer" products with keyboards/additional ports already available?

It seems you pay quite a premium for touch, I wonder if this machine will help sway people back into this form factor without touch/tablet mode.




As a Pixel owner I can confirm that touch on a laptop form factor is somewhat useless. There are precious few times I want to reach out to touch something instead of using the mouse.

The mouse really is a great tool. People need to stop trying to get rid of them.


I suspect this is a generational thing. Kids seem to reach for the screen to touch it all the time.


I (27, UK) was at a hackathon late last year where there were schoolkids (~17). They were all developing on windows 8 laptops, one of them even had a surface, and they all had brand new nokia Windows Phones.

This initially freaked me out until I realised that they were all learning VB at school (shudder), and were just tooling up to use what they already knew. I was encouraged that one of them had had a look at another language (Perl, of all things) and encouraged him to take a look at Python instead; citing xkcd of course.

Anyway, they were all very excited by touchscreen laptops, and actually using them while trying to do development. It was weird.


Oh don't get me wrong, people like to touch my screens. They just might not have any fingers left if they actually do. :)


Cute kids are supremely adept at taming finger biting demons.


Exactly. Just because we can now do basic car maintenance without a wrench, doesn't mean it's time to get rid of wrenches.


> 1. Do consumers want what is essentially a modern netbook?

Yes.

> Didn't this market die once the iPad and tablets took hold?

No, Chromebooks have been successful.


While I appreciate your response, I would love to see some actual data to back up your conclusions.



Top of Amazon doesn't really mean much.

http://conversations.nokia.com/2012/04/12/nokia-lumia-900-do...

Here's some analysis based on browsing data usage which shows sales were worse than Windows RT.

http://www.zdnet.com/first-real-world-usage-figures-suggest-...

If Chromebooks sales are good , why don't they release real official numbers?


True, but that Chromebook has been at or near the top since it was released almost a year ago.

Also Acer has already said 10% of their shipments are Chromebooks.

> If Chromebooks sales are good , why don't they release real official numbers?

Who is "they"? Chromebooks are released by several manufacturers, some of which have released numbers.

And if Chromebook sales are bad why do more of them keep coming out, with more manufacturers joining in?

I don't see manufacturers jumping on board the Windows RT train, do you?


Well google doesnt hesitate to brag with worldwide Android Activations and marketshare so why should it be different for ChromeOS?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: