Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is very neat. I've been using Backbone + ShareJS[1] to do a lot of similar things for a current app I'm building. This is certainly nicer, though, with concepts like latency correction and support for keeping the user's changes in place whenever a template updates by only updating the specific elements that change (very cool).

A couple of questions for you:

1) What's the current and projected goal in terms of concurrency for the server? Is this going to be able to handle thousands of simultaneous connections? Is the Node server built on anything else like Socket.IO, or is it fully new and unique code?

2) How does this handle conflicts? ShareJS implements Operational Transformation[2] to attempt to smartly handle conflicting writes from multiple clients (used in Google Wave, for example). Does this just do a simple timestamp-based overwrite? If so, how far down the tree? I'm not familiar with MongoDB (sorry), but would it be at the object level? Or the property level?

[1] http://sharejs.org [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operational_transformation




It looks like David Greenspan (the guy who created EtherPad and then got hired by Google to work on Wave) is on the team so it's probably safe to assume that OT is a feature.


A very good point :-). Just wanted to know what their "official" word is, since I didn't read about it in the docs...

EDIT: I see that they mention OT on the people page: http://www.meteor.com/about/people, so excuse my ignorance about the people behind the work...


Well you got me to read the whole Wiki page, that counts for something. And it's a feature to be pretty excited about!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: