Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Big fan of IPFS here, but silly question, isn't a status page suppose to have realtime updates of whether a service is online or not? This doesn't seem like a good fit unless you're using some realtime CRDT adapter on top like they list here https://github.com/ipfs/research-CRDT/blob/master/Readme.MD (disclaimer: I'm the author of https://github.com/amark/gun, which is one of the listed options). The StatusPage link is sparse on info, anybody know how it works underneath? Sorry if I'm confused on how status pages are supposed to work, can it really be static if it is supposed to be reporting services uptime liveliness (and thus requires some type of realtime monitoring)??



There seem to be two types of status-pages:

Really great ones show that all services are up, and often have timing information, graphs, or metrics, etc. An example of this would be https://status.bitbucket.org/

More basic status-sites generally only show useful detail(s) if something is currently broken, and perhaps will show you a summary of recent problems over the past few days. An example of that would be https://status.github.com/messages

(I wrote a simple status-page for my own site, but I elected to go the simple route. I do monitor availability and response-time(s) of various parts of the service, but I only update the site when there are problems, manually. This works for me because problems are rare, and my site is small.)


Thank you for these links!

So... This still seems problematic though - if you manually update it, then the hash of the page is going to change, and then you'd need to retrieve a different IPFS item than the original status page. And so on... No? This just seems like an odd loop.


When I manually update my site, that just means I add a file to the git-repository with today's date. Once I commit and push that a Makefile rebuilds my (static) site.

I don't personally use IPFS, but I imagine if I did then I'd have a script to change DNS, or update the hash IPFS uses. I see from other replies that updating the "most recent" version of a site is simple enough that it shouldn't be a problem in practice.


ipfs works by creating a URL based on the hash of the content that you're publishing. so ipfs.io/hash(MYSITEISDOWN) vs ipfs.io/hash(MYSITEISUP)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: