Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Go live in a world where theres no securitization of debt, no interest on debt, no mitigation of risk, no insurance against risk, hell even no banks.

No banks means no jobs, bad housing, no tools, no pc's, no security, no stores - but that dosnt matter, cause you dont have any money either, bad food, no mass production++

Most people commenting in this tread has no concept about what finance is and does, so it must be inherently evil.

Well, the world is more complex than that. Without finance your standard of living would probably be below one tenth of what it is now -unless you already live on the street of course. But then you wouldn't care because you'd probably be a alcholic or druggie. You won't get hold of any drugs or boose either so your fucked as well.

Tldr; The world runs on debt & oil. Get used to it, it isn't going to change anytime soon.




The key word here is innovation. Lot of the stuff you described (except perhaps debt securitization) is old and tested. To an outsider like me, it looks like a lot of financial innovation today (the kind that Wall Street does by hiring Physics and Math Phds)is primarily aimed at making a few rich people even richer at the expense of everybody else and provide zero or negative value to society. Why should we encourage that behaviour? Then there is the good kind of innovation like Micro-financing that is done in places like Bangladesh, and that you know, actually is designed to help the common man. Even crowd-funding (is that financial innovation?) could be considered good (although caution and regulatory oversight should be built in). This is kind of innovation seems to be the exception rather than the rule though.

I say financial innovation should treated by govt. with greater caution and suspicion especially when the effects of such innovation has consequences on the wider economy or when it involve other people's money.(Who's bright idea was it anyway, to allow banks and funds to gamble with people's pensions and deposits?)

If you can provide a counter-example to this, that would be much welcome.

edit: And no, I don't think a world without debt securitization would be such a bad thing.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: