Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Yes I know, and that's why longer fast work quite a lot better than short ones, you do lose weight like /crazy/. I seems to lose nearly 1Kg a day.



1kg of fat would be 9000 kcal. Impressive energy expenditure there. Of course a lot of water weight is lost initially (when fasting or just skipping all carbs) but that rate won't hold for weeks on end.


I thought in ketosis it wasn't energy expenditure, the liver causes fat to break down and pass through your bladder? ... maybe I have that all back to front though :\ Maybe ketones pass through your bladder and they also break down fat cells...


That sounds vaguely like diabetes.

In the absence of metabolic disease, the body breaks down fat to use the resulting energy. Think about it evolutionarily; "there's no food right now, time to jettison my energy stores"?


Ketosis is a pretty weird state brought on by lack of carbohydrates. The liver starts producing ketones, ketones rapidly breakdown fat cells to boost blood sugar.

It is mostly unrelated to diabetes as that relates to insulin response.


Blood sugar is not boosted by ketosis. Ketosis can occur as a result of low insulin (in which case blood sugar will be high).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ketosis#Mechanism

http://www.diabetes.co.uk/blood-glucose/ketosis.html


How do you make sure that your body doesn't burn up muscle while fasting?

Also, how do you keep sufficient energy to perform daily tasks and things like intense programming sessions?


Ever been in the middle of a hard workout and noticed that you smell like ammonia? That smell means you are burning protein, probably from your muscles. I have only ever seen this during extended exercise, but the same thing during a fast would be a clear indicator you are burning muscle.


So that's what that is! I used to notice that a lot when I first started cycling aggressively in college. Once I got into better shape it mostly went away. Thanks for the tip.


I haven't noticed any muscle lost -- but then again I put on muscle /very/ easily (a bit too easily actually, I get hypertrophia if I do too much sport). For energy, it turns out your body /does/ have some to burn, and once you made the switch to burning fat, well, usually there's a nice source of energy... I also wonder if you don't get a small dose of adrenalin in too, which would explain the 'high' you get after a couple of days.. but don't quote me on this..

But as I mentioned, the fruit juice input in the morning does help get the day started. Oh, and the coffee contains some nutrients too, so it's not like I'm totally starving.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: