Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> and the earned income tax credit is already hated by the GOP

They hate writing checks just to write checks.

You can get it passed if you sell it as a progressive subsistence voucher that will replace the minimum wage, medicaid (we still have an insurance mandate), food stamps, etc.

In fact, use the word voucher. The GOP loves those.

...and the GOP is more complex than people understand. I voted for Romney and McCain and I'd go for an EITC if it came with the right reform package. All this "if it weren't for those guys..." is really counterproductive.




Overall I thing the GOP has a great message, but they don't follow through.

Over the last 30 years the GOP has raised government spending far more than the Dems. Consider the Medicare prescription drug plan without any negotiation for lower rates.

It's just redicusly over the top levels of corruption.


>Overall I thing the GOP has a great message, but they don't follow through.

Can you name a political party, in any part of the world, in the last century that did follow through with their "great message"?

Politicians are PR / sales people. The product work is rarely actually done by them.

If mortgage interest rates on average went up, the politicians will blame the greed of banks, the international exchanges market, the gravity was higher than normal etc.

If mortgage interest rates on average went down, then that's a great reason to vote that politician in for another term!


UK Labour Party elected in 1945 removing Churchill from office - they founded the NHS.

People who had suffered through WW2 wanted to feel that there would be some benefit to the common people - 70 years later and the NHS is still one of the most loved institutions in the UK despite being avowedly a socialist endeavour.

NB I am not a supporter of the current Labour Party (AKA "New Labour") but they do deserve a lot of credit for what they did back then.


Many political parties can be credited with positive actions, but were those actions the "great message" that formed the basis they were elected on?

The nearest example I can see in recent history was the ANC in South Africa since 1994.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: