Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

World, maybe. But in terms of building a somewhat-self-sufficient community -- which seems to be what's being suggested here -- why wouldn't all-engineers work?



Land management, cooking, cleaning, child-rearing, teaching, schooling, animal husbandry, community health, repairs, safety, upkeep, music/arts/entertainment, policy... the list goes on

And while many engineers seem to believe they can do anything with applied knowledge -- practice and execution are two very different things.


> Land management

You mean "civil engineering"

> cooking

You mean "culinary engineering"

> cleaning

You mean "sanitary engineering"

> teaching

You mean "educational engineering"

> schooling

You mean "educational engineering"

> animal husbandry

You mean "agricultural engineering"

> community health

You mean "medical engineering" or "civil engineering"

> repairs

You mean "engineering"

> safety

You mean "engineering"

> upkeep

You mean "engineering"

> music/arts/entertainment

You mean "acoustic/visual/recreational engineering"

> policy

You mean "political engineering"

> the list goes on

And the list will still be refactored into engineering fields (some of which I may or may not have extracted from my rectum in an ad hoc fashion).

Engineering really just boils down to using the scientific method, mathematics, and ingenuity to solve problems. Pretty much every activity you described could very easily have an engineering mindset applied to it.


It doesn't have to be 100% self-sufficient, that's not what I meant. I was thinking more about a community of families living around the same farm and company.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: