Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> So to the person who is currently making $75k and watching their coworker getting a $30k raise does what, exactly?

Congratulate their coworker.

> Suddenly that person is worth 66% more

No. That person is finally getting paid what they're worth.

> so what about everyone else?

What about them? Did they suddenly lose money?

> Come salary review time, I'd be asking for a huge raise, ..., and if they're handing out 50+% raises, my value must have also increased.

Why would your value raise at 'salary review time'?

> because clearly the company has the cash to throw around

Why do you think it has money to throw around? If the company hires someone else, do you think the company has cash to throw around?

You're making a bunch of illogical statements that make bad assumptions.

Start with this: how does one person getting a raise increase your value later on? How does hiring someone else increase your value later on? Unless you can answer these two questions satisfactorily, you are just being petulant.




Wait, what? You seem to be saying that person who was making 45k was getting paid less than they were worth. And now that they are paid 75k they are "finally" getting paid what their worth. And the person who was previously making 75k was getting paid exactly what they're worth before and after? That seems like a bold claim. How convienent that everyone happens to be worth almost exactly the same.

It seems to me that the person who got the huge bump is now getting paid more than they're worth. If person A is getting paid 66% more than they're worth and person B is getting paid only what their worth then person B is going to be upset. Maybe they shouldn't be, but they absolutely will.


> No. That person is finally getting paid what they're worth.

I dunno about that, sounds like they are just getting paid more.


> I dunno about that, sounds like they are just getting paid more.

The free market has always been shitty about getting money to people who "deserve" it versus people who acquire it. If you think a high-paid lawyer is somehow worth the same as elementary school teacher, you should agree with the reduction in the massive disparity of salary. If you honestly think the lawyer is "worth" more, I don't want to know you, be around you, or have to interact with you at all.


I think salary and compensation don't correlate to the worth of a human being, but they do directly correlate with the value that the human being provides to a company. I feel pity for you if you consider your salary or other compensation a representation of your worth as a person. Do you think an elementary school teacher and a lawyer are 'worth' the same in the courtroom?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: