Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Thats what the most crazy evil people in history said in their defense: in the end, it would have been peace -- the mass murdering dictators.

There are better ways to achieve a better living for everyone. No one needs to suffer or to die for that. The path is important.




What exactly is your point in this thread? Are you somehow trying to draw an analogy between Bill Gates and "mass murdering dictators"?

We get it. Bill Gates made some reprehensible business decisions, in his time, that hurt people. He also made some good ones, and created vast amounts of wealth for many, many people. Microsoft continues to do so. I'd argue it nets out. Now, in the twilight of his life, he's spending his time and wealth helping society.

He didn't destroy the software world, or its "culture". What is it you do that allows you to throw so many stones?


Gates took wealth from many, many people and gave it to the few. It is the inversion of free software. You don't see how he hurt the society and how much more wealth could have been created without his decision.

I don't throw stones because of the mistakes someone made. I throw stones because of the lack of will or understanding why to fix the own mistake when he is capable of it.


"You don't see how he hurt society and how much more wealth could have been created without his decision."

"Gates took wealth from the many, many people and gave it to the few."

Those two sentences do not mean the same thing.

Your argument, when you boil it down, is that Bill Gates kept wealth and power for himself and his company, instead of allowing others to have it.

That's called capitalism, I think. I do good, I get money, I don't have to share it if I don't want to.


It isn't the point that Gates made money. The point is: at what cost?

In capitalism, its considered fair to hurt people within legislation, just to make oneself rich. It is argued as the market and "the better shall win", but we are far away from sane market mechanics. More often people suffer than profit from it. The overall goal is to make everyone happy. But this can't be achieved by our capitalism.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: