Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What who you rather get out of your tax dollars, roads and parks and fast internet, or explosives and ammo? Both mean jobs for Americans all the same. It's the value of the output that's different.

Why funnel efforts and capital into military instead of funneling the same into producing infrastructure, consumer goods, and advancing science? Yes, both are contributing to "the economy". One is creating collective value, the other is enriching military contractors and creating an incentive to wage war.




That's definitely not a false dichotomy. /s

People funnel money into the military because they are afraid of terrorists and whatever else is the flavor of the month.


> People funnel money into the military because they are afraid of terrorists and whatever else is the flavor of the month.

Do you know any individuals who personally decided to funnel money into the military? It's an insatiable beast fed by political breakdown and cronyism.


But those terrorists they are afraid of became terrorist because of our meddling in their affairs.

Ok, I know it's to "protect and defend out interests", but those interests are in somebody else's backyard and bedroom


You don't need many tanks to fight terrorists. Yet the army is forced to buy more tanks (against its own wishes!), because congressmen don't want the tank-production in their state to stop.


It definitely isn't a false dichotomy - money spent on military ventures is money not spent on e.g. space research.

What drives people to make the stupid choice is a different subject entirely.


That's not how federal spending works. There is no fixed amount so spending money on the military does not preclude spending money on space research. Similarly, cutting military spending doesn't mean those savings would go into any other budget.


"Why funnel efforts and capital into military instead of funneling the same into producing infrastructure, consumer goods, and advancing science?"

Because that's socialism, if not worse.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: