Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Um, yes. It is indeed overtly and primarily political once you have rewritten it to be.

I changed two words - I replaced America with France and "neo-liberalism" with "socialism".




Actually at first you used the word "communism", which is why I downvoted you and flagged your comment. You are just using inaccurate emotive language to rage wildly against a line in the article that offended your zealous patriotic/conservative sensibilities. You loudly complain about pretty much any article that contains a hint of politics you dislike. It just fills the comments with useless noise (I know I'm adding to it, but after seeing you do the same thing dozens of times it's getting pretty tiresome). If you don't like a submission, move on, don't post dozens of whining comments about how it hurt your feelings and how such submissions need to be banned from the site.


I actually flag all politics here, even the articles that agree with my political views, which are not at all what you seem to think they are, either.

It helps to get rid of these articles and keep the site a good one for startups/hacking/interesting articles, so for me it's worthwhile.

The article doesn't hurt my feelings: I think it's genuinely silly and low-quality.


An important part of flagging - and it is mentioned in the guidelines - is to avoid commenting that you've flagged the article.

Look at the low quality sub-thread that your comment spawned.


If no one explains that something is off-topic, how are we supposed to propagate that information, and the culture of what is on-topic to new users of this site?

That's an honest question, by the way. Since there is no barrier to entry to joining this site, there's nothing preventing masses of people arriving and crowding out the good content, which is of interest to far fewer people than politics are.

I'm more than happy to sacrifice otherwise useless karma in order to call stuff out, as the karma points serve no other purpose.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: