Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is installing a general-purpose computational device with audio listening and networking. In addition, its normal use case is listening for a phrase, doing additional decoding in the cloud, and then taking an action.

It is not at all unreasonable to say "Man, that functionality sounds a lot like spying. I sure hope that nobody roots this device."

Are you 100% sure (beyond some marketing copy on a website) that this is purely on-chip voice recognition? That this chip's firmware isn't reprogrammable? That it can't decide to, once activate on-chip once, stay on continuously?

You can't. Unless the hardware and software was open-source, and then was verified on-site, you can't. That's the problem with these kind of things.

And yes, we have the same problem with cellphones, laptops, tablets, soon cars, and everything else; that doesn't somehow magically make this any better.

Also, please stop saying "pathetic". It conjures to mind some jerk swirling cheap booze in a glass saying "mmm yes how pathetic the plebes" and then waiting for their next r/atheists post to get upvoted. You just end up sounding like a pompous ass.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: