Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

My favorite connected device is still an old iPad2 that I have connected to my TV. The advantages are:

1) The iPad has much better app support than most other TV connected devices. I can watch shows from Amazon, Hulu, HGTV, HBO, ... even the olympics have been well supported. The only issue I have is that there is no remote, and I don't see a good path to adding one.

2) I am a little less worried about privacy issues with it. Apple already has all of my emails, so the thought of them potentially listening to my living room with a connected device that has been well researched over the last few years isn't too big a concern.

3) The cost is low. For an older device that I no longer carry I would call it free. If you don't have a hand-me-down iPad to connect to the TV then the start at $300 new including an HDMI adapter, and you can find a used one much cheaper.

4) It is also a perfectly functional tablet incase you want to carry it around and look at the internet or something. It is old enough that new games are an issue, but it is fine otherwise.

5) It is already connected to the iCloud account with my shopping list, etc on it, so it can actually add things to a list or calendar that I use.

6) "Hey Siri", works well for me, and is enough to play the occasional song, or check wikipedia facts if I need one.

7) My dog is named Alexa, not Siri, so no conflict there.

Then again, other than the occasional electronic product I am pretty frugal. I know I am not a good target market for anything, so Amazon shouldn't try too hard to sell me on this. I think my old iPad is already working well as a better version of both the Fire TV and Echo.




> The only issue I have is that there is no remote, and I don't see a good path to adding one.

And that is the nail in the coffin for tons of users. If I have a device connected to my TV, and have to get up to open an app, play, pause, etc. that is a huge problem.

My favorite connected device is a cheap box running windows. I can watch shows from Amazon, Hulu, HGTV, HBO, olympics. It has two remotes (media remote and a wireless kb/mouse combo), I can beam youtube videos to it from my phone, watch any flash based video players, and can use the "full" internet easily. The only thing it's missing is some sort of siri/cortana/echo functionality, although I'm guessing that I could add it with some work.


> "Hey Siri", works well for me, and is enough to play the occasional song, or check wikipedia facts if I need one.

Siri works on the iPad 2? I thought it was only on later models.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: