Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's a matter of controlling that window and minimizing the number of affected sites.

Scenario #1: Release patch with no advance notice. Takes time for people to take notice and apply. In that window lots (12 million?!) sites get hacked. That doesn't sound like a very happy outcome.

Scenario #2: Announce a patch will be released in advance. Get the word out. Give people time to hear it. You're not giving any specifics other than there is some vulnerability. That's doesn't help any hacker, every product has some vulnerability. There'll probably be a lot less than 12M sites hacked. Also consider closing the vulnerability in ways that don't directly touch the affected code to make it more difficult to reverse engineer.

Obviously if everyone knows of the exploit you don't have the time but often the way hackers hear about the exploit is through your announcement...

[EDIT: Thanks to aryx above I learnt there was a 5 day window in this specific case (An Oct 10th announcement for Oct 15th security update). I don't think that announcement made it clear enough what the consequences of not applying the patch immediately would be. I think this is something that needs more careful consideration in the future.]




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: