Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Fossil fuels give us such good control over our climates that climate-related deaths ... have dropped precipitously over the past century...

What? Are you sure this isn't due to better construction materials and practices? I haven't heard this before.

Construction materials and practices, made possible by what fuel? What powers the excavators, drives the furnaces to used to make steel that goes into everything from rebar to Catepillar tractors to the steel toe in the foreman's boot? What source of energy do people use to get a log from a mountainside to the mill, through it, and then to your backyard? What are the hardhats that everyone wears made of? (Plastic, which is made from oil.) Need I go on?

This same energy source is very cheap. That means that more people can afford new(er) homes. Homes which are equipped with better features that help them resist natural disasters, such as earthquakes, hurricanes, extreme heat, cold, etc.

Suppose energy were 50% more expensive. It doesn't take an economist to predict that under those conditions, many homes wouldn't be as nice, new and safe. How many more people would have to do without air conditioning? Clean drinking water? How many more people wouldn't be able to afford fresh fruit and vegetables in the winter?




I think you're reaching quite a bit here. Oil is demonstrably more than 50% more expensive now than it was anytime before 1974, even adjusted for inflation. (I just double-checked.)

You seem to be saying that the price of energy not only underpins the entire world economy, but that it is the greatest factor in the world economy almost to the exclusion of everything else. I cannot believe that would actually be your argument, so I must be misreading you.

While the cost of energy is certainly a big factor (and I'd readily agree that cheap energy is largely responsible for the industrial age), the world civilization would have collapsed already if it were tied that closely to the barrel price of oil.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: