Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Wouldn't the solution involve allowing plugins to manipulate the content of a page before it is parsed by the browser?

There used to be a proxy adblocker that did that, but I don't think it works anymore.

The Kindle browser uses a proxy to pre-render pages on the server in order to lighten the load of the device.

Could AaaS (Adblock as a service) be a viable business? I think I'd pay for it.




> Could AaaS (Adblock as a service) be a viable business? I think I'd pay for it.

It probably could, however I'm sure it would be shut down quickly by advertisers and parties showing ads - after all, you're offering a service to remove their source of income. Unless you'd funnel part of your subscriber's income back to the advertisers, based on whose ads you block. But I'm sure it'd end up being too expensive for the consumer and too much of a hassle for the one offering the service.

Not to mention you'd force your users to funnel all of their internet traffic through your servers, and it wouldn't work with encrypted pages (which large parts of the internet is moving towards)


> It probably could, however I'm sure it would be shut down quickly by advertisers and parties showing ads

What legal leg would they have to stand on? There's no law that prevents me ripping out the ads of magazines that get delivered to me…


The same one that allows them to sue people for scraping their website.

Tech laws are absurd.


Privoxy - http://www.privoxy.org/ does just this and works very well when configured properly. It's also one of the few ways to reliably block ads on iOS apps.


You do have some information in the browser you can't get to from the outside. For example, the filter with the most hits for me is "@@||192.168.$xmlhttprequest", which whitelists XMLHttpRequests to 192.168.*. A proxy can't really tell the source of a HTTP request. But that kind of thing is sometimes the only indicator telling the difference between an ad and useful content.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: