HN's dup detector is crude and simplistic. Suggestions over the years to help fix it have been ignored, and efforts to help cross-link items have been lauded by some, and vilified by others who somehow seem to see the repetition as a feature. I guess that since it's documented (many times over, again, discussions repeated ad nauseam) it's definitely a feature rather than a bug.
Largely, I've given up. Let the discussions repeat the same points over and over - most don't care, others don't even notice. An engineer at heart, I find it almost physically painful to see such inefficiencies and loss of opportunity.
Not all duplication is bad. If you live to be long enough, you'll typically spot a cycle of stories carried in the mainstream media: local media's recycling of "places to visit" and "quaint historical anecdotes" items (new to me in my youth, somewhat less so in my dotage), the very, very predictable seasonal trend, particularly in consumer business stories around holidays, election cycles, etc.
In the case of HN, there are submissions I've seen which have gone down with no appreciable comment which, one or two or four years later, may well deserve a re-hearing. At the same time, you'll get iterations on a specific theme (a recent instance being 2^11 stories) which, while different in source, are often largely similar in content and significance. HN penalizes the former while passing on the latter. I'd prefer that reversed.
I've grown increasingly impressed with reddit's "related" link giving access to other discussions on a particular URL or topic. Actually, I've been growing increasingly impressed with reddit in general.
In a way, though, news is a cyclical thing. It comes up again and again. Maybe it's a good thing in this case; seems to be an instance of police brutality and wrongful arrest, so the more exposure, the better.
This story also brings out a couple of bits of information that we didn't get last time around, more of the police point of view.
7233730 : https://medium.com/p/9f53ef6a1c10/ [0]
7496137 : https://medium.com/human-parts/9f53ef6a1c10 [1]
HN's dup detector is crude and simplistic. Suggestions over the years to help fix it have been ignored, and efforts to help cross-link items have been lauded by some, and vilified by others who somehow seem to see the repetition as a feature. I guess that since it's documented (many times over, again, discussions repeated ad nauseam) it's definitely a feature rather than a bug.
Largely, I've given up. Let the discussions repeat the same points over and over - most don't care, others don't even notice. An engineer at heart, I find it almost physically painful to see such inefficiencies and loss of opportunity.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7233730
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7496137