Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Treating this as an either/or discussion overlooks the reality of business, and the world, which demonstrates that to be successful you need to do both.

Great Marketing + Crappy Code / Product = pets.com

Great Code + Crappy Marketing = The-next-big-thing-nobody's-heard-of-or-will-pay-for.

Probably the most telling part of this was talking about the "the world perception didn't seem to value the geek's contribution".

If you can't demonstrate value (which is marketing in a nutshell) then the value (which is business cashflow and profit in a nutshell) won't be there.




You can't tie features, product, and code quality together either. Even the most brilliant code is worthless if it isn't solving the customer's problem. This was the issue with Eric Ries' first version of IMVU - they built an epic piece of IM integration software that they trashed because no one wanted it.


so, in sequence then:

1) identify a problem that your customers want you to solve

2) solve the problem, sketchy at first and sound out your market about the solution you are offering

3) iterate a couple of times between (2) and (3)

4) your initial users are now your most valuable marketing tool, by now they have built a relationship with you and they should be happy

5) big rollout to all the users that you have that are comparable to your 'pilot' customers

6) back to 2! keep doing it, improve the product, fine tune your marketing pitch and do not ever forget about the one at the expense of the other.

With some variations this scheme works for both b2b and b2c.


I think that's a nice sequence for product-marketing development.

At some point you'll have to deal with all the business support stuff (Premises, HR, Accounts). And then when you get big enough and start hiring people to do most of the product-marketing work, then you'll need to have some business management aspects like Vision/Strategy, client base management etc.

But this process should serve you through ramen profitable, and beyond.


there is another starting point for 1.

1. identify a problem you can solve better than anything else on the market.

If everyone is using square wheels, build a round one, even if people aren't asking for it.

Sure, sometimes you loose with a superior product. But it's a pretty big advantage to have.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: