Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is a tangent, but I've always wondered... is it silly of me to be hesitant to use Android for the fact that Google owns it? I'd trust a jailbroken iPhone to do my bidding (and not be sneaky) more than an Android phone, but perhaps I'm being a bit crazy.

Still, it's hard to shake the feeling of an all-seeing eye watching everything I do when I use Android. I installed it in VirtualBox and there were at least five different options I had to turn off just to ask it to please not transmit my data to Google's servers: Auto-backup, location info, usage statistics, crash reports, and a couple others I'm forgetting right now.

Google has a vested interest in knowing as much about you as possible. Apple may have the same interest -- like I said, I'd trust a jailbroken iPhone rather than a vanilla one -- but they make their money by selling you hardware and apps.




If you're wary of Google, just don't create an account on the phone.

I've recently de-Googled a number of Android phones, and the cleaned-up experience is wonderful. Long battery life and plenty of apps from F-Droid or Amazon.

Browser-sync is nicely handled by Firefox Sync, which you can self-host.

Ideally it'll be a rooted phone and you can also delete all the com.google.*.apk files, too, so none of their apps run in the background ( uselessly spinning and burning CPU cycles in case you suddenly decide to create an account ).


Awesome! Are there any resources I could read to learn how to de-Google an Android phone? Thank you so much!


It's fairly straight-foward on the lastest versions of Android that allow you to freeze apps, rather than having to root and rename the apks.

Here's a list of the apps that are safe to remove, noting the Google ones:

http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2299805

If the phone has a Google account already configured, lock-out the phone by changing the account password on a PC. If its rooted, delete the accounts.db file.

Apps that I usually then install for the user:

- Osmand to replace Google Maps

- F-Droid and sometimes Amazon App Store

- K9 Mail ( you can even point this to G-Mail quite safely! )

- Firefox in place of the stock browser


Once your phone is rooted, use Titanium Backup (there may be similar apps on F-Droid for free) to uninstall the Google apps and services you don't need.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: