Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I suspect banning guns wouldn't really help. Japan doesn't have many, but they have lots of suicides.



The argument does not work in reverse. If they had more guns, there would probably be more suicides. End of story.

I am not suggesting that no guns == no suicides, because that would be ridiculous. I am refuting the suggestion that having a gun does not increase your risk of dying by suicide. I submit that having a gun nearby does increase your risk of dying by suicide with ample supporting evidence listed above. I am happy to read studies to the contrary, but it seems pretty clear to me at this point.


I don't think anyone is disputing that having a gun increases the likelihood of succeeding. I just disagree with the idea that the gun contributed to the attempt.

Most of what you just stated I have no disagreements with, but it is worded differently than what has been stated by others before.


Excellent point, a quick look says that it is the leading cause of death of men aged 20-44 and of women 15-34. Without a gun culture to speak of.

I wish you posted this earlier in the day. I could have used this information. Sad thing is, I knew this to some level but did not think of it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: