Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Pirate Bay's Weird New Business Plan (businessweek.com)
30 points by jmonegro on July 4, 2009 | hide | past | favorite | 12 comments



It's very tough to actually believe this article has all the facts straight when they suggest Seti@Home is a peer2peer network..... :o


It is. It's a common misconception that peer-to-peer is only about making the handshake symmetrical. Equal contribution of resources is the important thing. In the case of most peer-to-peer technologies, this contribution is in bandwidth, storage space, and tiny routing computations. In the case of seti@home, the contribution was cpu cycles.

http://www.amazon.com/Peer-Peer-Harnessing-Disruptive-Techno... has a chapter on Seti@Home.

For those not already running it, please install folding@home on your desktop computers. http://folding.stanford.edu/


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer_2_peer

Look at the 2 images on the right :) Seti@Home nodes connect only to the main server. They never see or hear anything about other nodes either. If the servers died the network would die.

But I second the Folding@Home prompting - a great cause!


Hate to be nitpicky, but for something to be peer-to-peer, I'd imagine peers have to be talking to peers... no such thing on Seti@Home :-/


ErrantX, you should plug your MUCH better article then:

http://www.errant.me.uk/blog/2009/07/pirate-bay-considering-...


Isn't this bordering on illegal? It sounds like they want to resell one ISP's bandwidth to another. As I understand it ISPs are already upset about bittorrent because it circumvents their commercial upload services by hijacking consumer bandwidth.

It sounds like a terrible idea.


It's letting consumers resell their bandwidth on-demand to (I suppose) whoever needs extra I/O right now.

Frankly, I love the idea of reselling bandwidth, it's reminiscent of selling power back to the grid.

As for upload speeds/services, I think that's all going to go away pretty soon -- the DSL/FIOS/Cable wars are heating up (at least here in NYC) and they're starting to compete in upload bandwidth. AFAIK, cable-internet systems are usually built with an asymmetric bias for downlink speeds, while the other two aren't.


ADSL is also built asymmetrically. You can do symmetric DSL but there is a trade off and you get a lower download speed than ADSL.

I select my domestic links by upload bandwidth since the download is fast enough.


I'll stick to private trackers. They are like governments - they work better when in smaller communities.


How exactly can you sell Comcast's bandwidth back to Comcast?


Quite weird indeed, but I figure by ISPs he means hosting providers. Something like earning money to offer legal content through BitTorrent would be quite interesting.


They'll be up against BitTorrent Inc in a way - and those are the official people!




Consider applying for YC's first-ever Fall batch! Applications are open till Aug 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: