Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Not really. I could buy them on DVD too instead of iTunes. The point is that copyright enables the production of these beautifully produced cartoons using a business model that's a simple cash transaction. No advertising, no privacy-destroying user tracking, just cash in trade for a product.



Copyright is not a divine right, it is granted as part of an exchange. Part of that exchange is that the copyright is granted for a limited time, after which the public can use the IP how they want.

If Disney and friends can change the deal to suit themselves, why shouldn't every consumer follow suit and make similar self-benefiting changes to the copyright deal and copy/consume Disney material without paying?


I could buy them on DVD too instead of iTunes.

If you buy them on DVD or Blu-ray you will be bombarded by advertisements, and they were probably unskippable until Disney added a skip button and called it an invention (AKA "Disney Fast Play").

No advertising, no privacy-destroying user tracking, just cash in trade for a product.

If only that were the case. Does iTunes state in its privacy policy or EULA that purchase and playback tracking data is not recorded or reported to content producers? What about consumer devices (connected Blu-ray players, smart TVs, etc.) that report back to their masters like the recently discovered LG smart TVs?


I have some Disney DVD. They have previews, but no ads.


They're basically the same thing. I'm not nearly as bothered by movie trailers as I am by most advertising, though.


Actually, part of the reason Disney films are so widely pirated is because you can't but them on DVD - their most popular films are only available on DVD for a couple of months every decade or so, and many haven't been released yet. Their business model is based largely around not making their product available. (Also, they dragged their feet spectacularly - it took the total death of the VHS market for them to move to DVD, just like it took widespread VHS piracy of their movies for them to release them on VHS.)




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: