Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If you're not willing to lay your own driveway, don't expect a highway to it.

If you're not willing to head for the front lines and fight as best you can, don't expect an effective national defense.

If you're not willing to confront criminals in your own home, don't expect police to track them down when they escape.

Yes, government's major role is to coordinate national-scale activities which serve everyone's interests. If you're not willing to do your part without that coordination, don't expect others to pitch in. Government is not some minor deity acting in pure benevolence, government is the aggregation of citizens doing their part and coordinating mutually beneficial activities. Government is the consequence of people consenting to negotiations over rights & responsibilities, not a bunch of know-it-all busybodies threatening to wreck the lives of anyone who does not submit to their whims.




None of those propositions make sense.

If I'm a renter, I don't have property to lay driveway on, and yet I have a need for highways. Combat is a job for trained soldiers; if a country needs to mobilize irregulars from the streets it has probably lost the war.

And the police generally advise that you do not confront intruders, but instead find a protected area and call 911. Apprehending criminals is the job of the police, regardless of whether they're in your home. Confronting them yourself is a great way to turn a burglary into a murder.

In a representative government, there is a legislative process required to authorize government action. It is neither necessary nor desirable to perform some small-scale imitation of a policy you would like to see enacted before advocating for that policy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: