Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What? No. You're completely misreading this. The situation with helium wouldn't be as dire if we were recovering it properly (which we're not, because of the economics of boneheaded political decisions as wikipedia describes). But once those deposits run out, the nearest economically viable source of helium is Jupiter. Seriously, no joke. This is a crisis.



This seems like a Simon-Ehrlich wager case. We don't know of an immediate way to stop the crisis, but does that mean we really will run out of helium before someone discovers a better method of production?

I am not an economist and I'm not going to bet $10k on it or anything, but I think it's reasonable to expect something to change the situation.


There is no method of production. None, zero, zilch.

Unless you mean, say, production of ionizing alpha radiation, capture and containment, in which case you're using up another scarce resource of radioactive source products, generating far more radioactive waste then existing dirty nuclear plants, all for an amount of helium that you need a laboratory to measure.

Or maybe you mean by fusion? In which case you'd need a fusion reaction which yields stable helium isotopes which can be extracted without including radioactive byproducts. The difficulties here make interplanetary trade seem like nothing.

Economics is not a magic bullet. You actually need viable choices first, which we don't have here.


I suppose if we get better at fusion we could electrolyze the oceans and fuse the hydrogen into helium.


Sorry could you explain how I'm misreading it?

As far as I can tell, all natural gas resources has a percentage of Helium. Since we won't be running out of natural gas anytime soon, we won't be running out of extractable Helium. It just isn't extracted right now because the US is dumping their stockpile. By 2015 this should be done, prices should spike because production was stopped and will take some time to restart, and then it'll go back to "normal".


We could theoretically harvest the solar wind for alpha radiation. It will be much more efficient near mercury and you could use all that energy to vaporize rock and climb the gravity well with the cargo.




Consider applying for YC's first-ever Fall batch! Applications are open till Aug 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: