Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> You still have to figure out what they are doing before you call

To me, something like “in Japan, people usually start their workday at 2100 (or at 2000 in winter)” seems less complex than “in Japan, people usually start their workday at 8:00, which is 2100 (or 2000 in winter)”.

> If your wake up, jet lagged, look at your watch, and it says 1800, are you too late for breakfast?

If you wake up, jet lagged, look at your watch, and it says 18:00—which place this time refers to?

I think having global time would be simpler (though it's impossible anyway due to politics and people's inertia).




...seems less complex than “in Japan, people usually start their workday at 8:00, which is 2100 (or 2000 in winter)”.

That's not how calls to Japan currently work, and I make plenty of them. You check the world clocks on your phone and see that it's 6:00am in Tokyo. You know what 6:00am means: it means what it has always meant for you and everyone else, everywhere in the world, since you and they were born. You decide to give them a call later. The end.

Life in different places on the globe is not synchronized just because you assign everyone the same universal clock time. You can either look up the local time in Japan, and know immediately what that means, or you can look up your clock time here, know immediately the clock time in Japan, and still not know what you need to figure out: what's going on right now in Japan. You still have to look that up somehow, but the answer won't be a simple local time that everyone understands intuitively, because local time maps differently to the daily cycle of life in every locale.

I think having global time would be simpler

Well, everyone's watches would say the same thing. That's the good news. The bad news is that they would all mean something different.

though it's impossible anyway due to politics and people's inertia

The inertia of things that work well in practice is a valuable shield against seemed-like-a-good-idea-at-the-time theories. I find UTC very useful for viewing astronomical events. When I need it, it's just another clock. It doesn't mean it needs to replace the far more useful local time for daily life.


Note that Japan doesn't have DST.

[... and thank god, because DST was nothing but a huge pain when I lived in countries that did have it. It has no place in the modern world.]




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: