Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Bitcoin has a gigantic first mover advantage. The free rider alt coins are all essentially based on Bitcoin's blockchain innovation.

Until Bitcoin is broken through advances in computing or a solution better than Bitcoin comes along, Bitcoin is the top of the heap for digital cash.




> Bitcoin has a gigantic first mover advantage

Not only that, but:

1) People with investment in hashing power tend to hash on bitcoin

2) If another coin were to come along (as they do, ask me about Terracoin) the speculators would find it.

3) The coin would be vulnerable to attack from those speculators who control even a tiny fraction of the hashes of Bitcoin.

I'm not just talking about double-spend, I mean someone (or several someones) with a large amount of hash power (say, each individually much smaller than 51% of total) coming along to service the network for a short while, driving up the difficulty, and getting away with a lot of coins while actually processing transactions for a comparatively short amount of time.

TRC, as a network with usually several terrahashes[2] hashing constantly, had to implement some controls[4] to prevent this kind of attack.

When the coin is more profitable to hash, the speculators find out, they bring their hashes, and it drives the difficulty up.

When the difficulty goes up, a slog ensues (the per-hash temporary advantage of mining Terracoin dries up) as the speculators take their hashes elsewhere and the remaining sloggers have only to hope that they can provide enough TRC at low cost[3] such that there is never an advantage to speculators, and thus the network can experience organic growth bringing in more permanent hashes from those who support its development.

The controls only limit the mobility of the difficulty (it can't shift up by 4x or down to 0.25x of the last retarget)

So when the slog is particularly bad (high difficulty), or when the hashing hordes are particularly voracious (low difficulty compared to coin price)... instead, it can increase to 1.25x or decrease to 0.75x -- you have to watch the network pretty close to see when people are getting over on profitability, but when they do you can still feel it for days.

The effect of not being the largest network seems to be that your difficulty goes up and down, not always just up up up. It's hard to find long-term difficulty reporting.[1]

Of course when bitcoin spenders are willing to wait up to 10 minutes for blocks, and Terracoin targets 2 minute blocks, even "network's running slow" seems pretty fast in relative terms, as long as it's not uncontrolled adjustment.

They must be doing something right, they're still/currently the most profitable Alt-SHA256 coin, even if the share prices have taken a serious dump.[5]

[1] http://pool.bitcoinreactor.com/pool/statistics/?cur=trc

[2] http://trc.cryptocoinexplorer.com/

[3] https://www.cryptsy.com/markets/view/27

[4] http://terracoin.org/news.html

[5] http://www.coinwarz.com/cryptocurrency




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: