Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I am an Ivy League alum from late last decade.

My financial aid grant was approximately 75% of tuition (before considering any federal loans).

I filed a FAFSA, and some direct paperwork required by the University. The paperwork amounted to less than 10 pages each year. I am not including the paper count of tax documents from my family.

There were several financial aid officers, but I worked closely with one. At every step of the process she was available to answer questions. I made several mistakes in my paperwork, even one after submission. My aid officer helped me with each issue.

My father passed away when I was in school. After I reported this to my University through my financial aid officer, they immediately waived all remaining tuition requirements (excluding those covered by federal loan grants). I did not pay a dime after that.

My family made about $60k a year, before my father's passing. $30k after. We own a house. I think we were middle class, but I am not sure how that is defined.

I got my aid officer a cake every year.




My financial aid grant was approximately 75% of tuition (before considering any federal loans).

They are just practicing price discrimination. They look through all your finances and consider exactly how much you can possibly bear to afford.

All that theater about giving you a 75% discount? It was just theater.


It's not "just" price discrimination, there are plenty of rich dumb kids out there that could have taken his spot.


Whether this anecdote is a true reflection of the wider system or not - this made me smile. Thanks for sharing :)

I have been exposed to a similar situation (though not from a US university, I was lucky enough to attend a private school in the UK. The tuition fees are roughly comparable): My best friend's Dad worked as a Vet until he had a heart attack. He lived, but couldn't work for a long time.

The school waived the final year of fees for my friend (~$52,000) - to my knowledge they have never requested it since.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: