Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Medical conditions (and often, medications taken to treat certain conditions) only make it more difficult to lose weight. They don't make it impossible.

I really don't like reading lines like "I eat right (most of the time) and I exercise (an inordinate amount), but it does little, thanks to a struggle with polycystic ovarian syndrome and a failing thyroid gland" because it suggests that weight loss is simply impossible for some people. And yet time and time again people with these and other weight-gaining diseases prove this wrong.

99.99% of the time people who struggle to lose weight are simply not following a successful weight loss plan to the letter. I would bet a pretty large sum of money, that if she got help (either online for free, or from a professional trainer/dietitian for not-so-free) and actually followed through with a proven action plan, the weight would come off. If she stuck to the plan, the weight would stay off.

It would probably be more difficult for her than for a healthy person, but to suggest that she has no choice but to be overweight is disingenuous.




Nowhere did I ever in any comment state or even imply that she had no choice. For you to characterize my position in that way is disingenuous of you.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: