Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Your straw man doesn't work. In a trivial sense, we are machines. There's nothing magic between quantum mechanics and a fully functional brain. Our soul is material, made up of neurons and other cells.

Just like a man-made machine, we are physical processes. We're just much better at self reference than the machines we build.




You've contradicted the statement that you made elsewhere - that it's the arrangement of atoms that matters. There's nothing magical about the processes, but the specific state matters.


An arrangement of atoms is a snapshot of a physical process. I don't see the contradiction.


An arrangement of atoms is a snapshot of a small part of a physical process with arbitrary boundaries drawn around it.


The boundaries are not arbitrary, to the extent we can factor the configuration space. For instance, we can draw a rather sharp limit between me, and the keyboard I'm typing with.


And what does that particular choice of boundary represent?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: