Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Bullshit.

Most startups are boring ass websites with none viable business ideas. They do not need baller engineers. If they have a working business eventually, they're competing to hire the smart folks based upon the mix of compensation, work and colleagues. If you can't build a biz that can sustain a compelling mix of those three hiring ingredients, you aren't allowed to successfully hire good engineers.

People: you aren't allowed to blame your crap hiring strategy on NYC finance firms scooping up all the smart engineers that wanted to work in finance. There are so many smart engineers who do / want live in NYC and Not work in finance. If you're failing to hire people it's because you have at least one of the following: a work environment that isn't a sane/pleasant place to spend 40 hours a week, crap compensation, or your biz is a CRUD website with the personality of a heavily used smelly sponge.

No particular category of business "deserves" smart people, they work hard to get those folks. And frankly, most startups are just crud websites. Additionally, the vast majority of interesting engineering challenges only happen at larger organizations. (That said, there are many small tech businesses that have really cool tech challenges, but that's the exception rather than the rule).

Let me restate that: most startups have boring work, terrible hours and crap pay.

Tl;dr to quote a favorite phrase of an awesome friend / software engineer: "fuck you, pay me money [if you want me to work with you]"

New York is a lovely place to live, one of the most truely urban and actually diverse locales one the planet. Certainly the only city in the US with subways that work 24/7 and good food at all hours. Not having to drive is a beautiful healthy thing.




Have you ever hired any technology talent in London? I have. It's exactly as I describe it. The city can afford to suck a huge amount of talent into is orbit by outbidding any startups - or most other businesses. It's not a factor if whether you have a great hiring strategy or not. It's the fact that you're competing against hiring managers with a good as unlimited budgets. This makes it hard to build a solid technology team without equally large budgets - whether you're a startup or a huge multinational corporation which just doesn't have the pockets of the City. This in turn makes startups in those places less competitive. Your rant notwithstanding this is something which makes it harder for those locations to create their own versions of Silicon Valley.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: