On: What is the rule for adjective order?

[stevenbedrick]

In case anybody's interested, one of our (former) graduate students has done some really fascinating work on computational analysis of prenominal modifiers (adjectives, etc.). For example, her ACL paper from 2011:

Mitchell, M., Dunlop, A., and Roark, B. (2011). Semi-Supervised Modeling for Prenominal Modifier Ordering. Proceedings of ACL 2011. http://www.aclweb.org/anthology/P/P11/P11-2041.pdf

[xfs → stevenbedrick]

Interesting conclusion from the paper:

[...] for ordering prenominal modifiers, [...] a simple n-gram model outperforms position-specific models

This seems to imply that adjective order can be better described with common phrases rather than a set of definite grammar rules.

[XaspR8d → xfs]

Thus the challenge of modern syntactic theory - to most it is clear there is some structure occurring, but attempts to quantify it are still beaten by rather naive statistical approaches.