I ran a little experiment... in a popular story, I said basically the same thing three ways:
Angry sarcasm: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=465422 (current score: -5)
Definition of my scope of knowledge, followed by the same opinion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=465428 (current score: -4)
One-sentence witty sarcasm: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=465436 (current score: 9)
Now, I really value our relationship, and it's meant to me more than any other coder/news-community relationship I could have imagined, but this isn't the Hacker News I feel in love with.
We all know "karma doesn't matter", but it definitely shapes the discussion that takes place. So let's reiterate some social guidelines which always helped this relationship flourish. I'll start:
- don't downvote things you disagree with, only things which are egregiously offtopic or seriously detract from the conversation
Karma is (or should be) a proxy for quality. But there are no mechanisms except social ones.
I also suspect that there are certain commercial "reputation" companies that have HN in their sights now. Not spammers per se, but father along the continuum to PR. There have been quite a lot of activity geared toward "whipping the froth" and post-storms around specific topics.
It may be time to fork HN. I actually also suspect PG has already forked HN for private YCombinator use. I haven't seen a post from RTM or TLB for over a year.