> I don't see how understanding asymptotic notation negatively affects someone's programming ability
Why would it make them worse?* I was just arguing it doesn't necessarily make them better. Just because you are a bad developer doesn't mean you get better when you learn about asymptotic behavior or heapsort or O-notation. Lots of really bad developers know about those things. And lots of really bad developers don't know about them as well.
Knowledge of those items is neither sufficient nor necessary to be either a competent or incompetent developer (at least for reasonable definitions of both competent and developer).
* Ok - maybe too much knowledge has some odd 2nd order negative effects on productivity: analysis paralysis, over-confidence, unwillingness to ask for help, programming toward a theoretically pure solution rather than a pragmatic solution.
Why would it make them worse?* I was just arguing it doesn't necessarily make them better. Just because you are a bad developer doesn't mean you get better when you learn about asymptotic behavior or heapsort or O-notation. Lots of really bad developers know about those things. And lots of really bad developers don't know about them as well.
Knowledge of those items is neither sufficient nor necessary to be either a competent or incompetent developer (at least for reasonable definitions of both competent and developer).
* Ok - maybe too much knowledge has some odd 2nd order negative effects on productivity: analysis paralysis, over-confidence, unwillingness to ask for help, programming toward a theoretically pure solution rather than a pragmatic solution.