Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"It has never won a medal at the winter games" is pretty misleading, given that India is largely a 'summer' country - in fact, it's pretty much just European countries, US and Canada that win medals at the winter Olympics. And while India's been to most of the summer Olympics, it's only been to 8 winters.

If you look at the medals won, it's clear that it's a very eurocentric competition. Apart from China (who go crazy for cold war reasons - the article disingenuously uses cold war countries for comparison), all the high performers are euro culture. Sure, Japan won 400 medals overall... but Germany has 1500... and even Finland has nearly as many summer medals as Japan.

Apart from China, who has invested heavily as a matter of pride, non-euro culture countries generally don't do well.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All-time_Olympic_Games_medal_ta...

Also, to be pedantic, the first sentence of the article is incorrect: Bangladesh has won zero medals.

I don't think it's a bad essay, but these were a couple of points I noticed.




There are plenty of "summer countries" that win gold in the winter Olympics. I recall one year Jamaica won gold with its bobsledding team.


Jamaica has won zero winter Olympics medals. Same with Brazil, Greece, Iran, Israel, Mexico, the Phillipines, Portugal (I stopped looking around p - check the link above) - all sizeable 'summer' countries with zero winter Olympics medals.

You probably recall the film "Cool Runnings", in which the team did not win; the point was that they were plucky underdogs and did better than expected, but they didn't place.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: