Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Close - this is a SDS-PAGE gel, and you run it using proteins. The bands in the first two rows are from a western blot (gel is transferred to a membrane), where you use antibodies against those specific proteins to detect them. The Pon S row is Ponceau S, a dye that non-specifically detects all proteins - so it's used as a loading control, to make sure that the same amount of total protein is loaded in each lane of the gel.



Is it conceivable that the control was run once because the key result came from the same run? I can see a reviewer asking for it in all three figures, whereas they may drafted it only in one


The horizontal label is fine, it says Pon S in all images. (I guess a wrong label would be obvious to detect for specialists.)

The problem are the vertical labels

In Figure 1e it says: "MT1+2", "MT2" and "MT1"

In Figure 3a it says: "5'-CR1", "CR2" and "3'-UTR"

In Figure 3b it says: "CR2", "CR3" and "CR4"


Based on the images, it is inconceivable that these are from the same run (see the dramatically different levels of TRF-S in each gel. One column/lane = one sample). This isn't something that would be included because of a reviewer - loading controls are required to meaningfully interpret the results (e.g. the data is useless without such a control).




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: