Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Homer Plessy

I read the entire Plessy entry. Nowhere does it say that he was “sponsored by the railroad” or anything like that.

The closest thing I could find is the following statement:

“The railroad company, which had opposed the law on the grounds that it would require the purchase of more railcars, had been previously informed of Plessy's racial lineage, and the intent to challenge the law.”

I agree with you that Plessy was handpicked, but you also wrote that Plessy “was sponsored by the railroad.” That is what I responded to, and I still don't see any evidence that it’s true. On the contrary, it seems clear that Plessy was selected and sponsored by a group that had no affiliation with the railroad company.

What evidence do you have that the Comité des Citoyens — which recruited Plessy, orchestrated his arrest, and organized the litigation in Plessy v. Ferguson — was connected to the railroad?

Rosa Parks

None of the things you quoted are evidence that Rosa Parks was selected in advance, by anyone other than herself, to engage in her famous act of civil disobedience. Parks’ own statements after the event indicate that she self-selected.

The fact that Parks was very involved in the NAACP is not evidence that the organization recruited her to engage in civil disobedience. Most of what you quoted is in relation to litigation that happened after Rosa Parks’ civil disobedience.

You also wrote that “Various civil rights organizations had guaranteed her family that they would replace any income lost.” What evidence do you have that Parks received such a guarantee prior to her act of civil disobedience?




I told you, I read it a long time ago. Disbelieve me if you wish. It's nigh impossible to find genuine information anymore on the internet, assuming that what I originally read is even still up.

I don't have enough time to play Wikipedia editor games about attribution. Believe me or don't.


Let them be well the trained P-Zombs they are, they can't know it any different anymore.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: