Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

So generators at multiple sites all failed in the exact same way, being unable to produce a stable voltage, even though they are all nearly new, have low hours, and are regularly inspected and tested.

It's impossible that it's an amazing coincidence they all failed on the same day. The fact they were all recently certified and tested means that that process doesn't work to ensure they will come on line any more than the process worked at Fukushima nuclear plant.

They don't give the manufacturer or model, and they say that they are going to have them recertified and continue to use them. So that means they are not going to fix the problem, because they don't know why they failed.

You can not fix the problem if you do not know what caused it.




To my ears - and maybe this is just wishful hearing - it sounded like they were very, VERY strongly pointing the finger at a certain unnamed generator manufacturer, but doing so in a way that incurred no legal liability.

That manufacturer is probably flying every single C-level exec out to the US-East data center, over the July 4th holiday, to personally disassemble the generator, polish each screw, and carefully put it all back together while singing an a cappella version of "Bohemian Rhapsody", including vocal percussion.

And if they do it to Amazon's satisfaction, Amazon has hinted that they might decide not to out them to the rest of the world. That's called leverage.


It was only at one site that the generators failed, but it was two generators in that site:

In the single datacenter that did not successfully transfer to the generator backup, all servers continued to operate normally on Uninterruptable Power Supply (“UPS”) power. As onsite personnel worked to stabilize the primary and backup power generators, the UPS systems were depleting and servers began losing power at 8:04pm PDT. Ten minutes later, the backup generator power was stabilized, the UPSs were restarted, and power started to be restored by 8:14pm PDT. At 8:24pm PDT, the full facility had power to all racks.

It sounds like they were too optimistic about their generator startup times.


The difference is that at Fukushima the generators were underwater from the tsunami. A bit difficult to get them started, in that condition.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: