On: Net 9.0 LINQ Performance Improvements

[mythz]

If it were trivial you'd see LINQ-like providers implemented in "practically every high level language".

Source code of the function means you have to implement the parser/lexer to convert it into a usable AST which is bad for both runtime performance and library size.

Very much doubt this is available in Java, which Java ORM lets you use native Java language expression syntax to query a database?

[pjmlp → mythz]

jOOQ would be one such example, https://www.jooq.org/

Not that I use this, I am a myBatis person in what concerns database access in Java, and Dapper in .NET for that matter, not a big ORM fan.

And case in point most people use LINQ for in-memory datastructures, not the database part.

[mythz → pjmlp]

This is a custom expression language to work within the expressive limitations of the language:

    create.select(BOOK.TITLE)
      .from(BOOK)
      .where(BOOK.PUBLISHED_IN.eq(2011))
      .orderBy(BOOK.TITLE)

If Java supported LINQ you'd be able to use a more intuitive and natural Java expression syntax instead:

    create.from<Book>()
     .where(x -> x.publishedIn == 2011)
     .orderBy(x -> x.title)
     .select(x -> x.title);

[pjmlp → mythz]

Java streams are what you're looking for.

If you insist in telling LINQ === EF, well that isn't what most folks in .NET use System.Linq for.

And back to the ORM thing, jOOQ is one way, there are others, and even if it isn't 1:1 to "from x select whatever" the approach exists.

[mythz → pjmlp]

> If you insist in telling LINQ === EF

I don't use EF, nor have I ever mentioned it.

You're replying to a thread about what it takes to implement a LINQ provider, which was dismissed as every high level language implements it with iterables, then proceed to give non-equivalent examples.

[recursive → pjmlp]

IQueryable<> manipulation has other tools available to it than brute-force iteration, like streams do. Streams may be the closest thing java has, but it's still a fundamentally different thing.

[megadal → mythz]

I mean they kind of are. You can find a library in almost every language that transpiles source code ASTs.

They're just not core features.

In Haxe, it's extremely common :) but Haxe is just one other high level language.