Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> I prefer junky fantasy books.

Kindle books like that are what fill in the gaps in my free time. One recent fantasy series I liked was The Good Guys/The Bad Guys by Eric Ugland. Somehow kept me turning pages.

some others (not fantasy) Infinity Gate by M.R. Carey; Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin;

But sometimes there is a lot of dreck to wade through.

Been thinking of making a "stop reading and discard book" list like:

- main character has unknown/dead parents, is secretly "the chosen one"

- no plot, character goes there, minimal opposition, gets all the stuff.

- anything harem




The problem with a "kill list" like that is that most of these overused tropes are overused because originally, they worked really well. E.g. if you strictly followed the first item on your list, you'd miss out on the Belgariad, which is really quite good (in my opinion, and that of the GP poster, at least. I'm personally less sold on the Malloreon, it's a bit too much of a retread for my taste.)

That said, I do agree that too many red flags like that and I will put down a book. And some are stronger than others; I'm 100% with you on the harem thing because any book like that is most likely just an excuse for all the sex scenes.


I think I need a "kill list" when I'm just not engaged with the book.

There have actually been plenty of books that probably had elements on the list, but were thought provoking, entertaining, or had excellent character development or some other novelty that I didn't even think of stopping.

It's also interesting to look at the list when you're thinking about continuing with book 2 or book 3.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: