Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Counterpoint to most of the posts here - I don’t see this and think “wow we should stop using things”, I see this and think “wow, we need to sort out governance / fix poverty”.

A well run landfill looks nothing like this and these are in no way a foregone conclusion of someone throwing away an old iPhone 3 or whatever.

There is no more correlation here than with, say, Newton has the apple fall and then we cut to scenes of firebombing.






This not “well run” landfill literally exists because the companies/countries dumping their e-waste here do not want to pay for the “well run” ones.

Sure, so let's make them pay for it, job done.

If I go to the loo and my water company decides it's cheaper to dump human faeces in the middle of the M1 motorway than to dispose of it properly, the solution isn't for me to stop going to the loo, it's to force my water company to stop doing that.


> make them pay for it

Which in turn will mean more expensive products. Products of imaginary Company A, which is responsible, will be more expensive than products of Company B, which can use all the tricks to be cheap (e.g. conflict minerals, child/slave labour, bribing^W lobbying government officials to take their e-waste).

And which products will the consumer buy? The better priced one...


Part of "making them pay" is making all of the companies pay, which makes your argument sort of moot. If not all companies are being made to pay, then you haven't done anything.

Yes, just like I use the cheaper electricity producer that burns coal.

Actually, no, my government doesn't allow this.


I leaved my last company because they dumped 10 to 15 15v bateries every day to the rubish.

There are laws against that. Impossible to enforce.


Stop going to the loo 20 times a day. Someone still has to clean up after you.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: