I see you're a new user: this type of comment is, by consensus and executive decree, not welcome on Hacker News. If you don't have something genuinely novel to contribute to the conversation, please do your part to keep the noise low.
This applies to the grandparent comment as well. If people seem to be jumping on your comment more than hers, it's because yours smells worse on the surface. But honestly, the grandparent is more insidious for being less obviously out of place but being similarly empty.
