Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What is the difference between lending a book in the library building and over the Internet from the library website? Lending over Internet is better because it saves the user from transportation cost, allows to read books at night etc.



THE DIFFERENCE IS THAT A COPY IS MADE.

They broke the law. This isn't that hard to understand. If you don't like the law then either work to change it, create substitute works, or break the law in a way that doesn't involve dragging down the archive with you.


Again, for clarification: this is the archive which contains copies of all those other web pages?

Should they have waited to start this archive, which is important enough for you to worry about its future existence, until the law on the right to make copies of websites was settled law? Bearing in mind that there are ongoing lawsuits and discussion on this topic right now, over fifty years since the emergence of the digital networks that rely on making copies to disseminate information.

Do you think that there was an open-and-shut case for an online archive in 1996?


So we should just ignore what was the intention with that law, and stick to the written rules even when it’s stupid in some new environments. Great idea!

When you watch anything on Netflix, the movie is copied a few dozens of times at least, and even you make a few copies during watching it, but I don’t think that it’s legal to make a copy, I’m quite sure that it’s stated in their ToS. So the whole internet infrastructure, and computer manufacturer, and every user should be sued with this logic.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: