Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Yeah, this has shades of "shining your shoes for the fat lady" to borrow a Salinger reference, and I understand that within the context of performance, but maybe I expect this to generalize farther than it does. There are many domains where a low cost, good enough solution is better. Not everyone can afford a piano tuner's exorbitant Sunday fee...



If we are going to bring cost into it, then digital pianos are superior in term of tuning (one might argue about other aspects of sound and feel). Same tuning every time, no adjustment needed.


>If we are going to bring cost into it, then digital pianos are superior in term of tuning (one might argue about other aspects of sound and feel). Same tuning every time, no adjustment needed.

I think they tune them slightly differently depending on what's going to be played. But I suppose a master pianist could have a whole database of their preferences saved up or something.


I bought a Kawai ca99 digital piano three years ago.

The feel is great. The simulated sound is pretty damn good, with a lot of attention to harmonics produced by undamped strings.

The built-in speakers do however quickly reach their limit when played at high volume and distortion artifacts can be annoying.

I'm not a professional pianist. I tried a few pianos both digital and some vertical pianos and I have to say that this one is the best instrument I have played so far.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: