Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Also free speech in law just means you can’t be prosecuted to say stupid things. It doesn’t mean that anyone owes you the canal to say your stupid things.

The previous twitter had (somehow) moderation. You would think what you want about it but you were free to use your free speech right elsewhere.

The difference is that Musk says that it gives you this canal but he lies because he is still moderating the network, except the moderation now favors far right content.

That’s not more free speech than before, that’s just a pro-fascist moderation.




Free speech is both an ideal, and something which is guaranteed by law (in some countries anyways). As a matter of law, you're correct. If you aren't prosecuted for your speech, then the law of free speech wasn't violated. But extralegal actions can still be (and often are) contrary to the ideal of free speech and are criticized on that basis. It is common, but erroneous, to conflate these two senses of "free speech".


I think when you say 'canal' you mean 'channel' (translating from French?), or more commonly 'platform'.


You are right, thank you




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: