Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Hard drives are non-magnetic & remain readable with good microscope indefinitively. They ALSO allow one to use superior error correction algorithms at ease (analog EC being possible). There exists no obligation to "always mitigate." Actually, from your comment it follows that one should not mitigate constantly.

For large archives, volume determines the cost, because the archive needs to be maintained at constant temprature, humidity etc. Digital storage, being much more dense, costs less.

Architecturally, this will also mean that the further distance between points A and B in the digital archive will grow, I would claim roughly exponentially, slower than what happens in the analog archive. This will affect the costs in myriad ways, which I at the time of writing don't recall.




I think you mean CDs/DVDs are non magnetic and can be read with a microscope.


And even with CD's there are issues.

Writable CD/DVDs have a written shelf life of about 25 years before the layers start to deteriorate and the best ones have a max lifespan guarantee of 100 years. They do rot, just slowly. With a microscope you can of course stretch that a bit but they won't last forever.


Perhaps I was wrong, thanks.


The CDs/DVDs use a metallic mirror. With the exception of certain expensive CDs made for archival purposes, e.g. by Kodak, which used a gold mirror, the reflective layer can oxidize in time, becoming transparent, when it no longer reflects the light.

The pressed CD-ROMs/DVD-ROMs still have pits in the polycarbonate disc, even when the mirror is no longer reflective. Those could still be read with a more sophisticated microscope, e.g. by using phase contrast.

The recordable CD-Rs/DVD-Rs used an organic dye for storing the bits and after a long enough time that dye can be completely degraded and it can become impossile to read.

The rewritable CD-RWs/DVD-RWs store the bits in a layer that can be either amorphous or crystalline, with different reflectivities. After a long enough time, that layer can recrystallize, erasing the bits.

Of all the optical discs that have been available commercially, those with the longest archival time were the pressed CD-ROM with gold mirrors, where the only degradation mechanism is the depolymerization of the polycarbonate, which could make them fragile, but when kept at reasonable temperatures and humidities that should require many centuries.

There have been experiments with write-once optical memories where the bits are stored in an inorganic glass that should easily last for many millennia, but until now I have not heard of commercial products. In any case, none exist at an affordable price.


The M-DISC should last for centuries in a typical vault, and they're about 3x the price of blank Blu-Ray.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-DISC




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: