Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> For me the real test is whether or not someone is trying to persuade other human beings towards a certain action. An action that is favourable for you.

I think the test for me, at least for the kind of marketing/advertising that should be banned, is the passiveness of it.

If, while going through my day, I am interrupted by your billboard, banner ad, spam email, promotional app notification, street marketing person, etc. in an attempt to manipulate me into action, that is the thing that should be illegal.

If I walk into a shop and say "I'm looking for a camera", invite a business in to pitch for work, call somoene up for a quote, directly enter a query like "buy camera uk" into a search engine, etc. then I think that is ok. I have asked to be sold to, and I am mentally prepared for the fact of that happening (notwithstanding that certain techniques should maybe also not be allowed).




Ok I agree with that. Attention intrusion is a bad thing. It’s the worst form of advertising I’d argue.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: