Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> absolutely there is some codec that apple licenses that you as a linux user don't and don't get

Such as?

Linux has had functioning AAC, MOV and MP4 drivers for almost a decade at this point. There are actually more codecs that Linux supports that Apple doesn't, like LDAC and APTx.




> Such as?

AAC-ELD is unsupported.

https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/issues/14...

> Linux has had functioning AAC, MOV and MP4 drivers for almost a decade at this point.

ok that’s nice but that’s not AAC-ELD. There’s no door prize for “part of the name is the same”, codecs and Bluetooth stream configurations are either supported or not.

It’s also not compatible with open-licensing either way, even though those licenses are commonly breached, ie it’s nonfree at best even if someone hacked together a toolchain, which was my point about the “free as in free from hdmi 2.1” part. Fraunhofer says you need to pay for a license even if you choose to pirate it anyway. Linux, by default, does not pay that for you (naturally).


Unless you're running a Guix system I don't see how open-license compatibility matters in the first place. I run my system, I install plenty of binaries and so does the majority of the Linux community.

> AAC-ELD is unsupported.

So is Airdrop. Pack up your crocodile tears and take them to a community that will do Apple's job for them. This is what you get for buying Apple products and insisting that the community reverse-engineers it to the quality of a documented and community-friendly platform. Blame Linux if you want.

> Fraunhofer says you need to pay for a license even if you choose to pirate it anyway.

Given that Linux supports DisplayPort alt-mode, this is kinda a nothingburger. Maybe my use-case is unique and contrarian, but I have never run into a situation with my laptop or desktop where I was gated from a usable experience because I didn't have HDMI 2.1. Hopefully nobody calls me out in the conference room for not showing my PowerPoint in HDR.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: