Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> I can't speak for everyone, but I can say that my life has gone far better starting from the premise of "this is the way I am and I have to work with that while recognizing the realities of interacting with a world that operates on different rules from mine" than it has from the premise of "I'm broken and I need to fix myself so I'm like others".

One may accept without either self-hatred or celebration. This is the way things are, this is what there is. No need to embellish either negatively or positively. I think either path leads to poor outcomes societally.




Sure, one may, but should one?

I might sound like a stoic, but I am definitely not one. The reason is that I spent a lot of my life trying to pretend I was above my emotions, unperturbed by such forces in my higher realms of logic. This...uh, wasn't true. I was feeling as much as anybody, and my actions were being guided by my feelings as much as anybody. I just wasn't listening to my feelings or aware of how much they were dictating about my life.

Emotions are as essential a part of a person as cognition is. The Universe doesn't prescribe any particular things as good or bad, praiseworthy or evil, interesting or boring. In the world of pure logic, there is no difference between me deciding today to not drink any water and dying in a few days versus me living a long, full life of rich goodness to my fellow man.

The problem is not having emotions, but confusing them with beliefs. Emotions aren't there to tell us what's a good idea, they're there to tell us what's a fun one. Both are important. So we use our reason and our emotional regulation to make better decisions about how we may have the most fun (where "fun" here is standing in for whatever broader notion of personal utility you might choose). Even the literal Buddha was pretty clear on the idea that there's not much value in depriving oneself of one's human pleasures - only in not being controlled by those impulses.

And I would say that taking satisfaction in the positive traits you have is a pretty basic human pleasure.


Can't speak for GP, but I have similar feelings... some things are dramatically harder, others easier... for the most part I just develop coping mechanisms for as much as I can and try to accept other pieces. Not a matter of self-hatred or celebration so much. Though I have dealt with a lot of depression in my life from a general difficulty in interaction.

One can reason their way through a lot of things, even a lot of the why's of emotion over time. To recognize when you are going into a state of reacting on emotion over reason. It's hard.

My daughter faces a lot of similar issues and it's harder for her than it was for me. The best I can do is try to instill a sense of drive to adapt and overcome as opposed to just giving up and/or wallowing in things. I wish my parents were better equipped to do this for me. I was close to 40 before a lot of things started to fit together. A few years ago, working with someone that had similar personality issues dialed to 11 so to speak that a lot of things became much more clear.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: