Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Given that the most meaningful jumps in my career have always been with the next company, agree.

Can't believe I almost got suckered into making a 'promotion packet', while being the one person on everyone's speed dial.

I already did the work, someone else just rewards it. Time and time again.




What do you mean making a promotion packet? Story, English is not my first language.


No need to apologize, it is a completely strange concept and I'm rushed!

Some places have existing employees interview for the job they want. They do this by making a 'packet'; a collection of documents proving things like business impact.

It's often put in front of a group of people with that job for review and they decide.

Normally, management, your peers, or the company as a whole are aware of your performance. They should be doing a lot of this for you, in my opinion.

It basically demands you do the job you want, before you have it. Some see this as fair, and I could agree, but not after 5+ years. I see it as a way to trick newcomers into overextending themselves.


Thanks for the explanation, all more clear now!


> Normally, management, your peers, or the company as a whole are aware of your performance. They should be doing a lot of this for you, in my opinion.

In company's with forced attrition rates, it becomes a hell of a popularity contest.

When Kevin Turner (former Wal-Mart exec) headed CSS (Customer Services and Support) at M$FT, it was a shit show and a half - creating something like a mandatory 5% attrition rate per year.

Nothing boosts morale better than people vying to NOT be the person let go that year. /s


Hah, true enough/fair.

Even in a business where it's routine to rest/vest, no 'crabs in a bucket' mentality required, these contests seem likely to appear.

One could simply exist/accrue an empire, yet... that's not enough. I suppose it's boredom.

Many reasons why we can't have nice things. Agh.


English is my first language and I don’t know what that means, either.


It refers to a document (or documents?) making the case why someone (themselves) should be promoted.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: